The Vague Plan Industrial Complex: How 'We Should Grab Coffee' Became America's Most Elaborate Group Performance
Photo: Karl432, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
There is a sentence loose in America that has launched ten thousand text threads and precisely zero Saturday brunches. It goes like this: “We should grab coffee soon.” It means nothing. It means everything. It is, depending on who is saying it, a warm gesture, a polite escape hatch, or a binding legal contract that the speaker will spend the next eleven months carefully avoiding.
We asked 400 Americans how they handle these vague plans — the ones made in hallways, at weddings, and in the parking lot of a Trader Joe's at 6:40 p.m. — and the responses revealed a nation of people with genuinely impressive evasion skills and absolutely no intention of ever drinking coffee with anyone.
The Survey: 400 People, Zero Intentions
The numbers are grim and hilarious in equal measure. Of the 400 respondents, 87% said they had said “we should hang out soon” in the past month. Of that group, 62% admitted they had no plan to actually schedule anything. And 19% said the phrase functions in their lives the way “how are you” does — a greeting, not an inquiry.
One respondent from Ohio described her technique with unsettling clarity: “I say it with a lot of warmth, and then I let physics handle the rest. If the plan wants to exist, it'll exist. I'm not going to force it.”
Another, from Oregon, put it more simply: “I love the idea of you. I do not love the idea of finding parking.”
The Excuse Economy Is Booming
When vague plans escalate into actual invitations, the creative writing begins. We asked people to share their most-used dodge, and the responses read like a short story collection about a person who is extremely busy and also possibly a ghost.
The classics remain undefeated. “This week is insane, but let's look at next month” won with 34% of the vote — a sentence so perfect it can be recycled indefinitely, since next month becomes this month and then becomes insane again. Close behind: “I'm so sorry, I totally missed this” (22%), “Rain check?” (18%), and a bold 9% who simply replied with the 😭 emoji and nothing else, which is technically a response and legally a dodge.
Then there are the artisans. One person admitted to using “my dog has a thing” as an excuse for four separate social events, despite the dog being a nine-year-old goldfish. Another confessed to inventing a recurring Sunday commitment called “family stuff” that no family member has ever heard of.
We are not proud of this, and yet we are all in the group chat doing it.
Calendar Tetris, Also Known as 'Let's Find a Time'
Here is where the real sport happens. The moment both parties pretend to schedule something, the conversation becomes a low-stakes negotiation with the tension of a hostage situation.
The most common strategy, used by 41% of respondents, is the Open-Ended Handoff: “Totally, send me some dates that work!” This sounds cooperative. It is actually a punt of the highest order, because sending dates means initiating, and initiating means the plan might happen, and then you'd have to put on real pants.
Twenty-eight percent prefer the Infinite Loop, in which both parties say “yes let's!” repeatedly over the course of six weeks without either one proposing a day. This can continue until one person moves out of state, which is, statistically, how most of these friendships end.
The bravest 11% go straight for the kill — a specific date, time, and location — and are subsequently treated by the group like someone who brought up politics at Thanksgiving.
The Moment Someone Actually Proposes a Date
Respondents described this moment with the dread usually reserved for a dentist appointment. “My stomach drops,” one 29-year-old in Texas wrote. “Not because I don't like them. Because now there's a calendar entry, and calendar entries are promises, and I am a person who has broken promises to my own gym membership.”
Another respondent said she once received a calendar invite with a Zoom link, an agenda, and a fifteen-minute buffer, and immediately felt the urge to fake her own disappearance.
Meanwhile, the 5% of respondents who are Actual Planners reported feeling “confused” and “slightly abandoned” by the rest of us. One woman in Chicago said she now has a personal rule: if someone says “we should grab coffee” and doesn't follow up within ten days, she simply assumes the friendship has transitioned to a mutual admiration from afar arrangement. Fair.
A Brief Defense of the Vague Plan
Here's the thing nobody wants to admit: the vague plan isn't always a lie. Sometimes it's a genuine, warm, slightly cowardly way of saying “I like you and I have no capacity.”
Forty-four percent of respondents said they said “we should hang out” because they meant it in the moment and then life did what life does. Forty-one percent said the phrase functioned as an act of kindness — a way to end a conversation on a high note without the cruelty of “no.”
And 6% responded, and we quote: “I'm not dodging anything, I'm just tired.” Honestly? Same.
The Tier List Nobody Asked For
We ranked the most popular evasions by how graceful they are, because we're a website and that's what we do.
S-Tier: “Let me look at my calendar and get back to you.” Elegant. Undated. Structurally unfalsifiable.
A-Tier: “I'm so slammed through the holidays.” Seasons change. Your excuse is eternal.
B-Tier: “Oh my gosh yes, remind me next week.” Delegates the labor. Bold.
C-Tier: The 😭 emoji. It's not a no. It's not a yes. It's a vibe.
D-Tier: “I'll text you!” You will not text them.
F-Tier: Actually scheduling the coffee. Absolutely unhinged behavior at this point.
The good news: you're not a bad person. You're just a person who says “we should grab coffee” the way other people say “bless you” — reflexively, warmly, and with no follow-through whatsoever. The bad news: your friend from college just texted. She wants to know if next Thursday works.